- 21
- February
Government agencies that have been using an ERP system for a while often hear this question from executives: "We have tons of data in the system, but why is it so hard to pull it together for a big-picture analysis?" — The reason is that ERP systems are designed to record daily transactions (disbursements, procurement, inventory receipts) — not to analyze historical data across departments or fiscal years. This article explains what a Data Warehouse is, how it differs from a regular database, and why government agencies should start thinking about one.
What Is a Data Warehouse?
A Data Warehouse is a large-scale data storage system specifically designed for analytics and reporting — not for recording daily transactions.
The concept was introduced by Bill Inmon in the 1990s, who defined a Data Warehouse as:
"A subject-oriented, integrated, non-volatile, and time-variant collection of data in support of management's decisions."
- Bill Inmon, Father of Data Warehousing
In simple terms, a Data Warehouse has 4 key characteristics:
| Characteristic | Meaning | Government Example |
|---|---|---|
| Subject-Oriented | Data is organized by subject of interest, not by the system that created it | "Budget disbursement" data from all departments and programs combined in one place |
| Integrated | Combines data from multiple sources into a unified format | Data from ERP + GFMIS + e-GP + HR systems consolidated into one consistent format |
| Non-Volatile | Once data enters, it is not modified or deleted — preserved as history | FY2025 disbursement data remains unchanged even if the source system is updated in the current fiscal year |
| Time-Variant | Stores data across time periods for trend analysis | Compare capital expenditure disbursement rates over the past 5 fiscal years by quarter |
How Is a Data Warehouse Different from an ERP Database?
Many agencies wonder: "We already have a database in our ERP — why do we need a Data Warehouse?" The answer is that they are designed for entirely different purposes:
| Aspect | OLTP Database (ERP) | Data Warehouse (OLAP) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Record daily transactions (disbursements, procurement, receipts) | In-depth analytics, executive reporting |
| Data Nature | Current data, constantly changing | Historical data accumulated over multiple fiscal years |
| Query Pattern | Read/write individual records, fast | Read large volumes, aggregate across tables |
| Schema Design | Normalized (3NF) — minimizes redundancy | Denormalized (Star/Snowflake Schema) — optimized for reads |
| Users | Operational staff (finance, procurement, inventory) | Executives, policy planners, auditors, analysts |
| Example Query | "What is the status of PO-2026-001?" | "How does Q1 FY2026 capital disbursement compare to the past 3 years?" |
In simple terms: An ERP database is like a "daily disbursement ledger" — it records every transaction as it happens. A Data Warehouse is like an "annual performance report" — it combines data from every ledger, every department, to analyze trends and support strategic decisions.
Core Components of a Data Warehouse
A Data Warehouse is not just "another database" — it is an entire architecture consisting of:
1. Data Sources
For government agencies, data typically comes from multiple systems:
- ERP System — Accounting, procurement, inventory, budgeting, HR data
- GFMIS — Government Fiscal Management Information System
- e-GP — Electronic Government Procurement system
- HR / Document Management Systems — Personnel and document data
- External Data — KPIs from the Bureau of the Budget, OPDC, State Audit Office
2. ETL Process (Extract, Transform, Load)
This is the heart of the Data Warehouse — the process of pulling data from various sources, transforming it into a consistent format, and loading it into the warehouse:
| Step | What It Does | Government Example |
|---|---|---|
| Extract | Pull data from source systems | Extract disbursement data from ERP and GFMIS every night at 2:00 AM |
| Transform | Clean, reformat, calculate new values | Standardize agency codes, calculate disbursement % vs. target, group by program/activity |
| Load | Load transformed data into the Data Warehouse | Insert new records into the Fact_Budget_Execution table daily |
3. Data Warehouse Storage
The main storage layer, designed with schemas optimized for analytics:
- Star Schema — A central Fact table (numeric data like disbursement amounts) surrounded by Dimension tables (e.g., fiscal year, agency, budget program)
- Snowflake Schema — Similar to Star but with further normalized Dimensions, suitable for complex hierarchies
4. BI Tools (Analytics Tools)
Tools that query the Data Warehouse to create dashboards and reports:
- Apache Superset — Free, open source — ideal for agencies that want to minimize licensing costs
- Metabase — Open source, user-friendly — create reports without writing SQL
- Power BI — By Microsoft, easy integration with various systems
- Tableau — Beautiful visualizations, ideal for executive presentations
Star Schema — The Most Popular Design
Star Schema is the most widely used Data Warehouse design because it is easy to understand and fast to query. It consists of 2 parts:
| Table Type | Purpose | Government Example |
|---|---|---|
| Fact Table | Stores measurable values (Measures) such as disbursement amounts, contract counts | Fact_Budget_Execution: date, program_id, agency_id, disbursement_amount, allocated_budget |
| Dimension Table | Stores context (descriptive data) used for filtering and grouping | Dim_Agency: agency_id, department_name, division, ministry |
Example: Star Schema for Budget Disbursement Analysis
Fact_Budget_Execution (center) connects to:
- Dim_Fiscal_Year — Fiscal year, quarter, month
- Dim_Agency — Department, division, ministry level
- Dim_Budget_Plan — Program, output, activity, project
- Dim_Expense_Type — Personnel, operating, capital, subsidy, other expenses
- Dim_Procurement_Method — e-bidding, specific method, selection
With this structure, you can instantly answer executive questions such as:
- "What percentage of capital budget did Department A disburse in Q1 vs. the Bureau of the Budget target?"
- "Which project had the highest procurement value in FY2026?"
- "Rank all departments by operating expenditure disbursement rate, highest to lowest"
- "Compare capital disbursement across the last 3 years, broken down by quarter"
Data Warehouse vs. Data Lake
Another term often heard alongside Data Warehouse is Data Lake. Both store large amounts of data, but they are fundamentally different:
| Aspect | Data Warehouse | Data Lake |
|---|---|---|
| Data Types | Structured (clearly defined schema) | Structured + Semi-structured + Unstructured |
| Schema Approach | Schema-on-Write (define structure before writing) | Schema-on-Read (define structure when reading) |
| Data Quality | High — cleaned through ETL | Varies — raw, untransformed data |
| Best For | Executive reports, dashboards, internal audit | Machine learning, deep analytics, raw document storage |
| Cost | Higher (requires schema design + ETL) | Lower (store raw data first, transform later) |
For government agencies that need executive reporting and audit-readiness for the State Audit Office, a Data Warehouse is the more targeted choice since the data is organized, high-quality, and ready to use immediately.
Why Should Government Agencies Have a Data Warehouse?
1. Cross-Department Executive Reports in Real-Time
Executives at the Director-General or Deputy Director-General level need to see the big picture across the entire organization — not just one department. But in an ERP, each module has its own reports. If you want to see "disbursement results for all departments + procurement status + staffing levels + remaining budget — all on one screen" — you need a Data Warehouse.
2. Support KPIs from the Bureau of the Budget / OPDC
Many government performance indicators relate to budget disbursement rates for both operating and capital expenditure. A Data Warehouse can calculate these KPIs automatically — no need to wait for staff to manually compile data from multiple sources.
3. Multi-Year Trend Analysis
ERP systems typically store the current and previous fiscal year — but a Data Warehouse stores data spanning many years for trend analysis:
- Is the capital disbursement rate improving or declining each year?
- Which types of projects are most likely to be delayed?
- Which expenditure categories consistently have the highest unspent returns?
- How does e-bidding compare to specific procurement methods over time?
4. Audit Readiness for the State Audit Office
A Data Warehouse stores data as Non-Volatile — once entered, data is never modified, with a complete audit trail. This allows agencies to retrieve historical data quickly when the State Audit Office or internal auditors need to review records.
5. Reduce ERP System Load
Running large analytical queries against the ERP database slows down the ERP for daily users. A Data Warehouse solves this by offloading analytics to a separate system, ensuring that daily operations remain unaffected.
Real-World Use Cases in Government
| Scenario | Without Data Warehouse | With Data Warehouse |
|---|---|---|
| Executive asks: "What is the capital disbursement rate?" | Staff must pull data from ERP + GFMIS, compile in Excel — takes 1-2 days | Open the dashboard, see it instantly — filterable by department, program, quarter |
| Auditors request 3 years of procurement data | Search through multiple systems and Excel files — may take weeks | Query the Data Warehouse instantly — complete, accurate, auditable |
| Preparing next year's budget request | Only 1-2 years of data available, lacks supporting evidence | Analyze 5-year spending trends by program and activity, creating data-backed budget proposals |
| Tracking strategic plan performance | Each department reports in different formats, impossible to consolidate | Real-time dashboard showing actual vs. target for every department and KPI |
How to Get Started — For Government Agencies
-
Start with policy questions
Don't start with "we want a Data Warehouse." Start with "what questions do executives need answered?" — e.g., disbursement rates by quarter, consolidated procurement status, remaining budget by program.
-
Assess ERP data quality
A Data Warehouse is only as good as its source data. If ERP data is incomplete, inconsistent, or inaccurate (e.g., some departments don't enter all records, some entries are miscategorized), fix the source first.
-
Choose tools appropriate for your agency
For government agencies concerned about software licensing costs, strong open-source options include:
- PostgreSQL — Free, open source, handles mid-sized Data Warehouses with no license fees
- ClickHouse — Column-oriented DB designed specifically for analytics, open source
- Apache Superset + Metabase — Free, open-source BI tools
-
Design the ETL pipeline
Define how data will be extracted from the ERP, how it will be transformed, and how frequently it loads into the Data Warehouse (daily? hourly?).
-
Start small — 1 subject area
Don't try to do everything at once. Start with the subject area of highest demand — such as "budget disbursement" — since every agency must report on it. Then gradually expand to procurement, inventory, and HR.
Saeree ERP and Data Warehouse
Saeree ERP uses PostgreSQL as its core database, which is a key advantage for government agencies looking to build a Data Warehouse:
| Advantage | Details |
|---|---|
| Open Source — No License Fees | Both the ERP database and Data Warehouse can run on PostgreSQL — no duplicate licensing costs, saving budget |
| Open Data Format | PostgreSQL data can be easily exported — no vendor lock-in, aligned with government Open Data policies |
| SQL Standard | Uses standard SQL, compatible with all ETL and BI tools — Superset, Metabase, Power BI, and more |
| Logical Replication | Stream data in real-time from ERP to the Data Warehouse without impacting ERP performance for daily users |
| Complete Data Structure | Budget, procurement, inventory, accounting, and HR modules have clear relationships — ready to serve as Data Warehouse sources |
A Data Warehouse is not an IT project — it is an investment in enabling government agencies to make data-driven policy decisions, report transparently, maintain audit readiness, and align with the country's Digital Government direction.
- Saeree ERP Team
Summary
- Data Warehouse is a data store designed for analytics, not for recording transactions
- Different from a database — stores historical data from multiple systems (ERP, GFMIS, e-GP), optimized for fast reads
- ETL Process is the heart — Extract, Transform, Load data from various sources into the warehouse
- Star Schema is the most popular design — Fact Tables (disbursement amounts) + Dimension Tables (fiscal year, agency, program)
- For government — enables executive reporting, KPI tracking, audit readiness, and data-backed budget planning
- Start with policy questions, not technology — what do executives need to know? Then design accordingly
If your agency is looking for an ERP system with an open database architecture ready to connect with a Data Warehouse, you can schedule a demo or contact our consulting team to assess your organization's readiness.
